Home
  Biography
  Contact David Curry
  The Skipton and Ripon Constituency
  House of Commons Debates
  House of Commons Questions
  Annuities Private Members Bill
News-cuttings and Articles


previous page

Prescott 'stripping grassroots of power' Tories attack move

Yorkshire Post - 13 February 2004

By Brendan Carlin Political Editor

John Prescott was last night accused of blatantly stripping powers from local councils in a desperate attempt to beef up his "milk and water" regional assemblies.

The Deputy Prime Minister yesterday announced that a Yorkshire mini-parliament would be able to overrule local councils approving large-scale developments. In a controversial move, Mr Prescott's department unveiled plans for any elected regional assembly to be able to veto major planning applications if the schemes contradicted a "regional spatial strategy" drawn up by the mini-parliament.

The powers were last night described by the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister as a "prime example" of how executive decisions would be devolved from Whitehall to the English regions if Yorkshire - as well as the North-East and the North-West - voted to set up an assembly in this October's referendum.

Mr Prescott's officials made clear an assembly would be able to intervene against contentious planning schemes without first referring the dispute to Ministers in London. That could include a major housing estate which contradicted regional guidance rules.

And Regions Minister Nick Raynsford said: "We recognise the people best placed to make decisions affecting the regions are the people who live in the regions".

But Tory regions spokesman David Curry branded the move clear proof that a regional mini-parliament would suck powers up from traditional local government - not take it down from London-based officials.

"This is a clear example of why Prescott's plans will take power from local councils," said Skipton and Ripon MP Mr Curry, who has already attacked the assemblies as feeble "milk and water" bodies. He also condemned the Office of the Deputy Prime Minister for formally announcing the move the day after a Tory-sponsored Commons debate centring on what the Conservatives believed were Mr Prescott's empty boasts of real powers for his assemblies.

The controversial planning move was mentioned in Mr Prescott's speech during that debate. But Mr Curry insisted that timing the formal announcement and details for the day after demonstrated "absolute contempt for Parliament".

As things stand, local planning authorities decide on applications in accordance with their own strategies for how development in their areas should proceed, in line with wider regional guidance.

And the Deputy Prime Minister, as the Minister ultimately responsible for planning, can "call in" major proposals such as that for a passenger airport at Finningley in South Yorkshire.

But under the assembly plans unveiled yesterday a Yorkshire mini-parliament could - having set its own "spatial" strategy for Yorkshire and the Humber - rule a specific development application out of order.
That would oblige a local planning authority, such as Leeds or Sheffield city council, to turn it down.

The voters of Yorkshire will decide this October whether to create a directly-elected assembly in a region-wide referendum. Three "hearings" are now planned in Yorkshire during March and April, with one likely to be in Sheffield, to see what powers people would wish the new body to have.

But, mindful of Tory claims they will be expensive "talking shops", Mr Raynsford signalled that more functions may be added to the proposed assembly's brief.

"Their powers will continue to evolve and it is important that people should get involved in the discussion about elected assemblies and the powers they need," he said.

© Yorkshire Post

back to top

David Curry MP | House of Commons, London SW1A 0AA | tel: 020 7219 6202